The position
A mortgage is not a product.
It is a structure
you live inside.
Which is why this site refuses the two shapes every lending site uses — the row of product names and the daily rate table — and orders everything by time instead. This page argues for that decision rather than assuming it.
What the industry organises by, and why it fails you
Nearly every lender site is built in one of two shapes. The first is a row of product names — Conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, Jumbo — with a paragraph under each that assumes you already know why you would want it. The second is a rate table, refreshed daily, each number attached to conditions in a footnote you have no way of evaluating. Both are catalogues, and catalogues are excellent things: they work for the second-time buyer, the broker, and anyone already told which box they belong in.
They fail everybody else in a specific way rather than a vague one. A product name is institutional vocabulary, not a description. FHA is the agency that insures the loan; VA is the department that guarantees it. Neither word tells you what the loan does to your bank balance in year four. Asking someone to choose between five agency names before they know what the names refer to is asking them to guess, and the guess is settled by whichever name they have heard before — a marketing outcome, not a financial one.
The rate table fails worse, because it looks like information. A rate is one number extracted from a structure with a dozen moving parts, and the extraction throws away everything that separates one loan from another: what you hand over on day one, what is still charged in year two, what stops in year nine, what the balance looks like at fifteen. Two loans a tenth of a point apart can differ by tens of thousands of dollars over the years you hold them. Ranking by rate is ranking by the wrong column.
So this site uses the one axis every reader already understands without being taught it: time. Five depths, from the morning you sign to the far end of a thirty-year schedule. At each depth a different question is live, a different set of rules applies, and only two or three of the eight programmes have anything to say. You never meet all eight at once, because you never face all eight decisions at once.
Day one
What you hand over
How much do I need, and what am I charged once?
What this depth decides. How much cash leaves your account, and which of the one-time charges you have quietly agreed to pay interest on for thirty years.
Programmes decided here
Work it out
This is the only band where the money is cash. Everything else on this page is a meter running quietly in the background; day one is the morning you hand over a cheque and sign a stack of paper. It is also the band that decides whether the purchase happens at all, because a shortage of cash stops a file that a shortage of income would only have shrunk.
The structural point is that the one-time charges have completely different shapes, and are almost never compared. An FHA upfront premium of 1.75% of the base loan amount is financed into the loan by default, so it never shows up in your cash to close — it shows up as interest, for as long as you keep the loan. A VA funding fee behaves the same way, and is waived for veterans receiving compensation for a service-connected disability. A discount point is cash now for a lower rate later. Three fees, three shapes, and a rate table shows you none of them.
Two things here are on your side, and both are deadlines rather than favours. Your Loan Estimate has to reach you within three business days of a complete application. Your Closing Disclosure has to be in your hands at least three business days before consummation. Those days exist so you can read the documents without someone standing over you, and the best use of them is to put two Loan Estimates side by side and compare the costs rather than the rate on page one.
0–3 yr
What is still being charged
What am I paying that will one day stop?
What this depth decides. Which parts of your monthly payment have an end date, and whether that date is fixed by law, by your loan-to-value, or not at all.
Programmes decided here
Work it out
The early years are where two loans that looked identical on the rate sheet stop looking identical. What separates them is not the rate; it is the set of charges that are temporary, and the schedule on which each one ends. Nobody reads that schedule, because it is nowhere printed as a schedule. It is spread across a servicing agreement, an insurance certificate and a note.
The clearest case is the comparison the industry never draws for you. Conventional borrower-paid PMI is not permanent: under the Homeowners Protection Act you may request cancellation at 80% of the original value, and the servicer must terminate it automatically at 78% of that original value, provided your payments are current. FHA annual MIP on a thirty-year loan with less than 10% down runs for the life of the loan, and nothing but a refinance ends it. Two charges that share a name in ordinary speech; one has an end date written into federal law and the other does not.
That difference is often worth more than a quarter point of rate, and it is invisible on any tool that reports a monthly payment. It only appears once you plot the charge against time.
3–7 yr
The window most loans actually end in
What if I do not keep this loan for thirty years?
What this depth decides. Whether everything you paid on day one was worth it, which is entirely a question about how long you stay.
Programmes decided here
Most mortgages end long before their term, by a sale or a refinance. That fact ought to reorganise the whole conversation, and almost nowhere does. A thirty-year loan is priced and compared as though you will hold it for thirty years, when the honest planning horizon for most households is three to seven.
Once you accept that, decisions that looked like matters of taste turn into arithmetic. Buying points, taking a lender credit for a higher rate, and refinancing are the same calculation wearing three hats: an amount now against a saving per month. Divide one by the other and you get the month it pays back. Leave before that month and you lost. The answer depends on a number only you can estimate, and the estimate is usually optimistic.
Two rules are worth knowing before anyone tries to move you quickly. Refinancing your principal residence gives you a three business day right of rescission under the Truth in Lending Act: you may walk away after signing, without penalty, for three business days. A purchase gives you no such right. And a refinance restarts the amortisation clock, which is how a lower payment at a lower rate can still cost more in total interest than the loan it replaced.
7–15 yr
When the house starts paying you back
What can I do with the equity I have built?
What this depth decides. What the equity you have built is actually for, and what you are putting at risk to reach it.
Programmes decided here
Work it out
By this depth the balance has fallen and, in most markets, the value has not — a combination that opens a door closed on day one. It also introduces the product on this site where the marketing and the mechanism are furthest apart. A home equity line of credit is a revolving account secured by your home: you draw, repay and draw again, usually at a variable rate tied to an index, and usually paying interest only. Then the draw period ends and the balance has to amortise over a fixed number of years.
The payment steps up on that morning, often to double or triple what it was, whether or not anything else about your life has changed. That step is the product. Everything written about the draw period describes the easy half. A home equity loan is the other shape — one lump sum, fixed rate, fixed schedule, no step — and choosing between them is a choice about shape, not about rate.
Both sit behind the first mortgage, and both are secured by the house. Lien position is about the lender’s risk. From where you sit, the collateral is the place you live, and that is as true of the second loan as it was of the first.
15–30 yr
Where the interest stops being the story
What does the far end of this actually look like?
What this depth decides. Nothing, if you are honest — which is exactly why it is worth looking at. This band is arithmetic, and it does not negotiate.
Work it out
At the far end the arithmetic stops being programme-specific and becomes simply arithmetic. On a level-payment loan every payment is the same size, but the split inside it moves month by month from interest towards principal, and the crossover arrives far later than nearly everyone expects. That is not a trick played on you by a lender. It is what charging interest on a declining balance does, and it is identical for FHA, VA, USDA, conventional and jumbo.
This band is also where the last piece of vocabulary gets straightened out. A jumbo loan is not a loan for a particular kind of borrower, whatever the brochures imply. It is defined by size: a loan larger than the conforming limit the Federal Housing Finance Agency publishes for that county and that year. Cross the limit by a dollar and the loan is priced and underwritten by the lender rather than bought by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. The borrower did not change; the county line and the calendar did.
The trade we are making
Plinth publishes structure. It does not publish rates.
That is a real cost, and it deserves to be stated as one rather than dressed up as a principle. You cannot shop us on price from this site. For a reader who has already done the structural work and only needs a figure, this site is worse than a rate table, and we would rather say so than pretend the omission is generosity.
What we get in exchange is the ability to be exact. A rate you have not been underwritten for is a guess with a decimal point on it: it moves with your credit, your loan-to-value, the property type, the occupancy and the lock period. Publishing one invites you to compare it with a number built on different assumptions, and the comparison is meaningless in a way that looks precise. The rules on this site hold for everyone. Seventy-eight per cent is seventy-eight per cent. Three business days is three business days.
Every dollar figure a calculator here produces is labelled illustrative where it appears, with the assumptions printed underneath, because a figure you generated from your own assumptions is worth more than one we generated from ours. The rate is an input, and it is yours. So is the number of years you think you will stay — the figure that changes more answers on this site than the rate does, and the one nobody ever asks you for.
The honest summary: read down the section, find the depth your own question lives at, and go and argue with the arithmetic there. Then take what you learn to a lender who has actually seen your file, and ask the specific question instead of the general one.
Start at the depth your question lives at.
Plinth Home Lending is a design demonstration. The company, the address, the phone number and the email domain are invented. No licence, NMLS identifier, rate, approval or timeline on this site is real, and no form on it transmits or stores anything.